8.2 Three cases for λ

As usual we consider the cases λ > 0, λ < 0 and λ = 0 separately. Consider the Φ equation first, since this has the most restrictive explicit boundary conditions (8.10).
λ = −{α}^{2} < 0 We have to solve

Φ'' = {α}^{2}Φ,
(8.11)

which has as a solution

Φ(ϕ) = A\mathop{cos}\nolimits αϕ + B\mathop{sin}\nolimits αϕ.
(8.12)

Applying the boundary conditions, we get

\begin{eqnarray} A& =& A\mathop{cos}\nolimits (2απ) + B\mathop{sin}\nolimits (2απ), %&(8.13) \\ Bα& =& −Aα\mathop{sin}\nolimits (2απ) + Bα\mathop{cos}\nolimits (2απ).%&(8.14) \\ \end{eqnarray}

If we eliminate one of the coefficients from the equation, we get

A = A\mathop{cos}\nolimits (2απ) − A\mathop{sin}\nolimits {(2απ)}^{2}∕(1 − cos(2απ))
(8.15)

which leads to

\mathop{sin}\nolimits {(2απ)}^{2} = −{(1 − cos(2απ))}^{2},
(8.16)

which in turn shows

2\mathop{cos}\nolimits (2απ) = 2,
(8.17)

and thus we only have a non-zero solution for α = n, an integer. We have found

{λ}_{n} = {n}^{2},\kern 2.77695pt \kern 2.77695pt {Φ}_{ n}(ϕ) = {A}_{n}\mathop{ cos}\nolimits nϕ + {B}_{n}\mathop{ sin}\nolimits nϕ.
(8.18)

λ = 0 We have

Φ'' = 0.
(8.19)

This implies that

Φ = Aϕ + B.
(8.20)

The boundary conditions are satisfied for A = 0,

{Φ}_{0}(ϕ) = {B}_{n}.
(8.21)

λ > 0 The solution (hyperbolic sines and cosines) cannot satisfy the boundary conditions.

___________________________

Now let me look at the solution of the R equation for each of the two cases (they can be treated as one),

{ρ}^{2}R''(ρ) + ρR'(ρ) − {n}^{2}R(ρ) = 0.
(8.22)

Let us attempt a power-series solution (this method will be discussed in great detail in a future lecture)

R(ρ) = {ρ}^{α}.
(8.23)

We find the equation

{ρ}^{α}[α(α − 1) + {α}^{2} − {n}^{2}] = {ρ}^{α}[{α}^{2} − {n}^{2}] = 0
(8.24)

If n\mathrel{≠}0 we thus have two independent solutions (as should be)

{R}_{n}(ρ) = C{ρ}^{−n} + D{ρ}^{n}
(8.25)

The term with the negative power of ρ diverges as ρ goes to zero. This is not acceptable for a physical quantity (like the temperature). We keep the regular solution,

{R}_{n}(ρ) = {ρ}^{n}.
(8.26)

For n = 0 we find only one solution, but it is not very hard to show (e.g., by substitution) that the general solution is

{R}_{0}(ρ) = {C}_{0} + {D}_{0}\mathop{ ln}\nolimits (ρ).
(8.27)

We reject the logarithm since it diverges at ρ = 0.